B2R, CJEU, EU Law, Family Law, Hague Convention

AG’s Opinion in Case C-335/17 Valcheva v Babanarakis

Advocate General Szpunar proposes that the Court of Justice rules that in matters of parental responsibility rights of access include the rights of access of grandparents. EU law provides for a single and uniform rule of jurisdiction which is that of the authorities of the Member State of the child’s habitual residence. Ms Valcheva, a Bulgarian national, is the maternal grandmother of a minor child born in 2002. Since his parents’ divorce, the child has been habitually resident in Greece with his father, a Greek national. His grandmother wishes to obtain rights of access. Finding that she was unable to maintain quality contact with her grandson and having unsuccessfully sought the support of the Greek authorities, she applied to the Bulgarian courts for a determination of arrangements for her to exercise rights of access to her grandson.

She requested that she see him regularly one weekend each month and that he stay at her home for two or three weeks during his holidays. The Bulgarian courts of first instance and appeal dismissed the action on the basis of lack of jurisdiction on the ground that an EU Regulation (Brussels IIa Regulation) provides for the jurisdiction of the courts of the Member State in which the child has his habitual residence (here, the Greek courts). Hearing the case at last instance, the Varhoven kasasionen sad (Supreme Court of Cassation, Bulgaria) takes the view that in order to determine the court having jurisdiction, it is essential to ascertain whether or not the Brussels IIa Regulation applies to the rights of access of grandparents.

Continue reading “AG’s Opinion in Case C-335/17 Valcheva v Babanarakis”